How does watch consignment work at Pucks & Timepieces?

You send us your watch, and we handle everything: professional photography, listing creation, marketing, buyer communication, and the sale. Once your watch sells, you receive payment minus our agreed-upon commission. We also offer direct purchase if consignment isn't preferred.

What is the commission rate for consignment?

Our commission rates are competitive and vary based on the value and desirability of the timepiece. We'll discuss the exact terms upfront before you commit, so there are no surprises. Contact us for a personalized quote.

Can I set a minimum sale price for my consigned watch?

Yes, we work with you to establish a target price and minimum acceptable price before listing. We'll never sell below your approved minimum without your explicit consent. Our goal is to maximize the return on your timepiece.

Sell Your Watch - Timepiece Consignment

Q: Is my watch insured during consignment?

Yes, your watch is fully insured while in our possession. We take the security and protection of consigned timepieces very seriously, with secure storage and comprehensive insurance coverage throughout the consignment period.

Q: How long does it typically take to sell a consigned watch?

Sale timelines vary depending on the brand, model, condition, and market demand. Popular models from brands like Rolex and Omega often sell within 2-4 weeks. Less common pieces may take longer. We'll provide a realistic estimate when you consign.

Luxury Watch Consignment at Pucks & Timepieces

Looking to sell your luxury watch and get the highest possible return? Our luxury watch consignment service is built for collectors and watch owners who want top-dollar value without the hassle of selling privately. At Pucks & Timepieces, we handle every detail — from professional authentication and high-resolution photography to strategic pricing and targeted marketing across our network of serious collectors and buyers.

Whether you're consigning a Rolex, Omega, Breitling, Panerai, IWC, Tudor, or any other premium timepiece, our experienced team ensures your watch is presented at its best. Based in Middleton, Wisconsin and serving collectors nationwide, we combine deep market knowledge with a hands-on, personalized approach that larger consignment platforms simply can't match. We also make direct purchase offers if consignment is not preferred.

How It Works — 3 Simple Steps

Submit Your Watch

Fill out the form below with your watch's brand, model, reference number, and condition. Include photos if you have them — our team will review your submission and provide an initial consignment estimate within 24 hours.

Authentication & Pricing

Ship your watch using our insured, prepaid label — or visit us in person. Our watchmakers authenticate your timepiece and we photograph it professionally. Together, we set a competitive market price based on current demand and comparable sales.

We Sell, You Get Paid

Your watch goes live on our platform and is marketed to our buyer network. When it sells, you receive prompt payment via wire transfer or check — no hidden fees, no surprises, full transparency throughout.

Start Your Consignment

Complete the form below with your watch details and we'll be in touch within 24 hours with a consignment estimate.

Why Consign with Pucks & Timepieces?

Expert, Market-Driven Valuations: Our pricing is backed by real-time market data, recent auction results, and years of experience in the pre-owned luxury watch market. We research every comparable sale to position your watch for maximum return.
Professional Presentation: Every consigned watch is photographed in-house with professional equipment, showcasing your timepiece in the best possible light. First impressions matter, and our listings consistently attract serious buyers.
Global Buyer Network: Your watch isn't just listed on one website — we leverage our extensive network of collectors, dealers, and enthusiasts to connect your timepiece with qualified buyers who appreciate its value.
Transparent Process: We provide a clear breakdown of consignment fees upfront. From intake to payment, every step is communicated clearly and promptly — no hidden charges, ever.
Fully Insured: Your watch is insured from the moment we receive it through the completion of the sale, including insured shipping during transit.

Frequently Asked Questions

What brands do you accept for consignment?

We accept a wide range of luxury watch brands including Rolex, Omega, Breitling, Panerai, IWC, Tudor, TAG Heuer, Cartier, Glashütte Original, Blancpain, Grand Seiko, and many more. If you're unsure whether we'd accept your watch, submit an inquiry — we're happy to evaluate any quality timepiece.

How long does it typically take to sell a consigned watch?

Sell times vary depending on the brand, model, condition, and market demand. Popular references from Rolex, Omega, and Breitling often sell within weeks. Less common models may take longer, but our team actively markets every consignment and keeps you informed with regular updates.

What are your consignment fees?

Our consignment fees are competitive and vary based on the watch's value. We provide a complete, transparent fee breakdown before you commit — there are never hidden charges or surprise deductions.

Can I set my own asking price?

We work collaboratively on pricing. Our team provides an expert valuation based on current market conditions and your watch's specific condition. We discuss pricing strategy together and factor in your expectations while ensuring the price is competitive enough to attract serious buyers.

Do I need the original box and papers?

While original boxes, papers, warranty cards, and accessories can significantly increase your watch's value and appeal to collectors, they're not required. We can consign your watch without them — though having a complete set typically results in a higher sale price.

Is my watch insured during consignment?

Yes. Your watch is fully insured from the moment we receive it through the completion of the sale. We also use insured shipping for transit, giving you complete peace of mind.

What happens if my watch doesn't sell?

If your watch hasn't sold after the agreed consignment period, we'll discuss options — adjusting the price, extending the period, or returning your watch at no additional cost.

How do I get paid once my watch sells?

Payment is processed promptly after the sale is completed. Choose wire transfer or check — whichever you prefer. We confirm the exact payout amount before the transaction is finalized.

Looking for other options? Sell or trade your watch for immediate payment, or explore our watch sourcing service to find your next timepiece. Questions? Call us at (608) 440-8835.